In this smart survival guide for students and teachers — the only book of its kind — James Elkins examines the “curious endeavor to teach the unteachable” that is generally known as college-level art instruction. This singular project is organized around a series of conflicting claims about art: “Art can be taught, but nobody knows quite how”. Elkins traces the development (or invention) of the modern art school and considers how issues such as the question of core curriculum and the intellectual isolation of art schools affect the teaching and learning of art. He also addresses the phenomenon of art critiques as a microcosm for teaching art as a whole and dissects real-life critiques, highlighting presuppositions and dynamics that make them confusing and suggesting ways to make them more helpful.